The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration opened a preliminary safety evaluation in mid-September 2025 into roughly 174,290 model-year 2021 Tesla Model Y SUVs after owners reported that exterior door handles stopped working, in some cases leaving children inside while parents were locked out.
What NHTSA investigation PE25010 covers
According to the agency's Office of Defects Investigation opening memo, PE25010 focuses on electronic door locks that receive power from the vehicle's 12-volt low-voltage battery. NHTSA received nine Vehicle Owner Questionnaires describing an inability to open doors from the outside. A preliminary evaluation is the first step before the agency could seek a recall if it decides the condition poses an unreasonable safety risk. No injuries or fatalities were reported in the filings reviewed so far.
Which vehicles are affected
The probe is limited to the 2021 Model Y, Tesla's compact electric SUV and one of the best-selling battery-electric nameplates in the United States. Later model years are not part of this opening action, though NHTSA said it will monitor additional reports. Tesla equips the Model Y with flush exterior handles that extend when you approach with a key or phone, and with manual interior releases that a child may not reach or know how to use.
What owners reported
The most common scenario in the NHTSA filings involves a parent stepping out after a drive—or before one starts—to buckle a child into the rear seat, then finding that no exterior handle responds. In four of the nine reports, the owner broke a window to regain access. The agency noted that repair invoices tied to those incidents often show replacement of the 12-volt battery, yet none of the owners reported seeing a low-voltage warning on the dashboard before the handles failed.
Why the 12-volt battery matters on an EV
Electric SUVs still rely on a small 12-volt battery to run locks, computers, touchscreens, and accessories even when the large traction pack is fully charged. On the 2021 Model Y, NHTSA's problem description states that electronic door handles can become inoperative when door-lock circuits receive insufficient voltage from that 12-volt supply. That is separate from the high-voltage pack that drives the wheels. Owners on forums and in service records commonly replace the 12-volt unit every three to five years; Tesla mobile service appointments often run about $120 to $200 for parts and labor, while independent shops or a DIY swap with an aftermarket Group 51R battery can land near $250 to $300 if you are far from a service center.
What you can do while the probe is open
Until NHTSA completes its review, owners of affected 2021 Model Y vehicles can take a few practical steps. Learn where the manual interior door releases are on each rear door and show older children how to use them. If the touchscreen warns about low-voltage battery health, schedule service promptly rather than waiting for a no-start event. After parking, confirm you can reopen a rear door from the outside before walking away if a child remains inside. You can also file a complaint with NHTSA if you experience a similar failure; those reports help the agency measure scope and severity.
What a 2021 Model Y costs to run in the United States
Ownership math for this model year is broader than door hardware. Used 2021 Model Y examples commonly list between about $28,000 and $38,000 depending on trim, mileage, and battery size. Full-coverage insurance averages near $219 per month for a 2021 Model Y nationally, though states such as Texas and Louisiana run higher and Hawaii lower, so request quotes before you buy. The EPA rates a 2021 Model Y Long Range all-wheel drive at 122 MPGe combined; at a residential rate of $0.16 per kilowatt-hour, 15,000 miles of home charging works out to roughly $650 to $700 per year if you skip frequent DC fast charging. Edmunds estimates about $4,100 in scheduled maintenance over five years for this vintage, excluding collision repairs; real-world owners note that tires wear faster on the Model Y's weight and torque, with a full set often costing $800 to $1,200. Registration fees vary by state—several add annual EV surcharges on top of standard plate costs—so check your local DMV schedule rather than assuming a single national figure.
Shopping used? Verify history and voltage health
A pre-purchase inspection at a Tesla-aware shop should include a load test or voltage check on the 12-volt battery, not just a scan of the high-voltage state of charge. Ask whether exterior handles were ever replaced and whether the seller has service records for prior lock or window repairs. Logging 12-volt battery replacements and door-related repairs in CarDiary helps you compare a 2021 Model Y against other used SUVs without relying on a seller's memory alone. You can also run the VIN through CarDiary's VIN check tool to review basic history before you negotiate. NHTSA's PE25010 investigation may eventually lead to a recall, a service campaign, or no action; either way, the 12-volt system is inexpensive to maintain proactively and costly to ignore when it fails without warning.