Car maintenance blog

NHTSA’s Tesla FSD Probe PE25012: Red Lights, Wrong-Way Lanes, and What Supervised Drivers Owe the Road

Federal safety regulators are scrutinizing Tesla Full Self-Driving again, this time for something every licensed driver...

Federal safety regulators are scrutinizing Tesla Full Self-Driving again, this time for something every licensed driver already knows by heart: red means stop, white lines mean stay in your lane, and oncoming traffic is not your lane. The difference is scale. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration opened Preliminary Evaluation PE25012 on October 7, 2025, covering an estimated 2.88 million Tesla vehicles equipped with Full Self-Driving (Supervised) or Full Self-Driving (Beta). The file is not a recall and does not order owners to stop using the feature. It is an engineering investigation into whether certain FSD maneuvers violate ordinary traffic laws and whether the car warns the human supervisor in time to prevent harm.

What PE25012 is actually reviewing

NHTSA’s Office of Defects Investigation says it is assessing the scope, frequency, and safety consequences of FSD executing driving maneuvers that constitute traffic safety violations. The opening resume groups the alleged behaviors into two buckets that show up again and again in owner complaints and crash reports filed under the agency’s Standing General Order on crash reporting.

The first bucket is intersection and signal behavior: proceeding or attempting to proceed against a red traffic signal, and improper lane use inside the intersection, such as driving straight from a turn-only lane or turning from a through-only lane. The second bucket is directional mistakes that read like navigation errors on paper but are terrifying in traffic: entering opposing lanes of travel, or attempting to enter a road marked with wrong-way signage, sometimes during a lane change.

When the investigation opened, NHTSA cited 58 reports tied to these patterns, including 14 crashes or fires and 23 injuries. A later information request to Tesla, dated December 3, 2025, raised the complaint count to 62 and added media reports and additional Standing General Order submissions. Tesla characterizes FSD as an SAE Level 2 partial automation system: it can steer, brake, and accelerate under some conditions, but the human driver must remain engaged and ready to take over immediately. NHTSA’s question is whether FSD sometimes commands moves that contradict signs and signals while the interface still feels confident enough that a tired supervisor misses the moment to intervene.

Why the name “Full Self-Driving” matters in a legal sense

On U.S. roads, liability and licensing rules still treat you as the driver even when software is doing the wheel work. State motor vehicle agencies issue licenses to people, not to neural networks. Insurance policies and crash reports still list the person in the left seat. That is why PE25012 spends pages on “indications and warnings”: whether FSD tells the supervisor accurately and early enough what it intends to do at the next intersection.

Tesla markets the current product as FSD (Supervised), stressing oversight. Critics—including some former regulators—argue the branding suggests a finished robot driver and encourages hands-off habits. NHTSA’s probe sidesteps that debate in public filings and sticks to measurable traffic-law behaviors: did the vehicle enter the intersection on red, did it face oncoming cars, did it use the wrong lane for the maneuver it chose. Those are the same facts a police officer would write in a citation narrative, whether or not software initiated the move.

What a Preliminary Evaluation does—and does not—do for owners

A PE is the early stage of a federal defect inquiry. Investigators collect complaints, crash data, and manufacturer documents. They may expand the probe, upgrade it to an Engineering Analysis, or close it if they find no safety defect pattern. Opening PE25012 did not require Tesla to disable FSD nationwide, and NHTSA has not published a consumer stop-drive order tied to this file.

That lack of a shutdown order cuts both ways for everyday owners. You may still engage FSD where Tesla allows it, subject to state law and local road conditions. You also remain legally responsible for complying with traffic control devices in every state you drive through. If FSD begins a lane change toward oncoming traffic or rolls toward a stale green that turned red, the correction must come from you, immediately, with no assumption that the car will abort in time.

Tesla has been responding to NHTSA information requests on a rolling schedule; agency memos show partial extensions into spring 2026 for large data productions about FSD (Supervised). As of fall 2026 the evaluation remains a live docket item on NHTSA.gov, which means outcomes could still range from a software remedy campaign to a closed file with no further action.

Scenes drivers describe—and how to supervise them

Complaint narratives in federal databases rarely read like marketing copy. Owners describe the car “committing” to a left turn from a straight-only lane, or accelerating toward an intersection as the signal turns red. Others report the vehicle drifting into an opposing lane during a lane change on a divided highway. These are not subtle ADAS edge cases like lane-centering wobble in a construction zone; they are binary violations that other motorists interpret as aggression or impairment.

If you use FSD regularly, treat every intersection as a flight lesson: hands near the wheel, foot covering the brake, eyes on the signal phase and the crosswalk, not on the center display. Before entering complex urban grids, many experienced supervisors disengage automation entirely. Highway merges and left-turn pockets with multiple paint arrows are other common disengagement points, because map data and camera interpretation lag the painted rules.

Document unusual behaviors with date, route, software version, and whether you intervened. That detail helps service advisors if Tesla publishes a targeted update, and it mirrors the evidence NHTSA collects under the Standing General Order. Saving each FSD software version and install date in CarDiary’s service history gives you a plain timeline if regulators later tie a specific release to changed intersection behavior.

How PE25012 fits next to other open Tesla dockets

NHTSA already maintains several Tesla investigations unrelated to PE25012’s traffic-law focus—door handles, headlights, and other hardware or compliance threads appear elsewhere on the defects site. PE25012 is distinctive because it targets driving policy encoded in software: interpreting signs, signals, and lane markings the way a human examiner would during a road test.

The investigation also lands amid broader industry scrutiny of Level 2 systems that blend automation with human fallback. Other manufacturers face probes over school buses, emergency vehicles, and stopped traffic. PE25012’s Tesla-specific detail is the allegation that the car itself initiates illegal moves rather than merely failing to prevent a human error.

Practical steps while the file stays open

  • Read NHTSA’s public resume for PE25012 and check periodically for updates; federal investigations can add vehicles or behaviors as new reports arrive.
  • Install Tesla software updates promptly, but do not assume an update closes the federal question until NHTSA says so in a recall or closure notice.
  • Know your state’s rules on hands-on-wheel monitoring; some jurisdictions treat advanced assist features more strictly in crash investigations even when the feature was engaged.
  • If you are buying a used Tesla, ask which FSD package is transferred and review any open investigations separately from the purchase inspection; CarDiary is a private log, not a government registry, and it does not replace a professional pre-purchase mechanical check.
  • After any near miss with automation engaged, file a complaint with NHTSA if you believe the vehicle violated traffic laws without adequate warning; owner reports feed defect statistics even when no crash occurred.

Federal probes move slowly by design. PE25012 may eventually produce a recall-like software remedy, a compliance letter, or a quiet closure. Until one of those endpoints is published, the operating rule for U.S. drivers stays unchanged: FSD is assist technology with a famous name, not a chauffeur. Red lights, wrong-way arrows, and turn-only lanes still belong to you.

  • #Tesla
  • #FSD
  • #NHTSA
  • #PE25012
  • #driver assistance
  • #traffic safety
  • #United States
  • #Full Self-Driving Supervised
https://www.car-diary.net/build/assets/flag-en-Dien0O0O.png https://www.car-diary.net/build/assets/flag-en-gb-CFOpQedK.png https://www.car-diary.net/build/assets/flag-bg-MsiRXCLT.png https://www.car-diary.net/build/assets/flag-ro-CaHXANk0.png https://www.car-diary.net/build/assets/flag-el-BVHqgjTL.png https://www.car-diary.net/build/assets/flag-de-DOA3ZfaR.png https://www.car-diary.net/build/assets/flag-fr-BtfubWT6.png https://www.car-diary.net/build/assets/flag-es-iVTog9Oi.png https://www.car-diary.net/build/assets/flag-it-Ct7RLwXx.png https://www.car-diary.net/build/assets/flag-pl-OWgefiF6.png https://www.car-diary.net/build/assets/flag-hu-BxooiC-Y.png https://www.car-diary.net/build/assets/flag-cs-CQ0GPA3W.png https://www.car-diary.net/build/assets/flag-sk-Di2-hul_.png https://www.car-diary.net/build/assets/flag-hr-CFGT8V6D.png https://www.car-diary.net/build/assets/flag-nl-CeqTqx21.png https://www.car-diary.net/build/assets/flag-pt-BXdczVE-.png https://www.car-diary.net/build/assets/flag-sl-DBDq2xzK.png https://www.car-diary.net/build/assets/flag-da-CcE_SpnG.png https://www.car-diary.net/build/assets/flag-fi-kHDHHAV-.png